You may have noticed that Fall is here. No, it’s not because you have to sift through your sweater boxes before you head out into the morning chill. Nor is it because your yard is covered in leaves that force you to trade hours of football watching for hours (and hours) of raking.
No, the new marker of fall's arrival is PUMPKIN SPICE! From lattes to ice cream to bagels to muffins to pancake mix to… Well, you get the idea. Ever since Starbucks introduced the world to Pumpkin Spice Lattes, we’ve become obsessed with all things Pumpkin Spice.
So, you’re probably expecting a blog post on creating fall cocktails using pumpkin spice. Sorry to disappoint. Life goes on after pumpkin spice, especially in the cocktail world. So, here are six cocktail recipes that taste like fall without a hint of pumpkin spice.
Background: A fall variation on one of America’s oldest cocktail templates.
Preparation: Stir whiskey, maple syrup and bitters with ice until properly chilled. Strain over a large cube in a rocks glass. Express an orange peel over the drink and garnish.
TPS Tip: Use real maple syrup, but don't overdo it. The goal is to soften and complement the whiskey, not turn an Old Fashioned into breakfast.
Background: The Moscow Mule dates to the 1940s, but its basic formula—spirit, citrus, and ginger beer—makes it extremely adaptable. Apple cider turns it into an easy fall cocktail without losing the bite that makes a Mule refreshing.
Preparation: Fill a copper mug or highball glass with ice. Add vodka, cider and lime juice. Top with ginger beer and stir gently. Garnish with a thin apple slice and cinnamon stick.
TPS Tip: Bourbon works beautifully here, too. Substitute it for the vodka, and you get a richer, warmer drink that's especially good on a cold afternoon.
Background: The Whiskey Sour has been around since at least the 19th century. Cranberry adds tartness, color, and a distinctly fall character without radically changing the original sweet-sour-whiskey formula.
Preparation: Add ingredients to a shaker. If using egg white, shake first without ice for about 10–15 seconds. Add ice and shake again vigorously. Strain into a rocks glass over fresh ice—or serve up in a coupe.
TPS Tip: Skip cranberry “juice cocktail” if you want a more sophisticated drink. 100% cranberry juice is considerably more tart, so reduce the amount or increase the simple syrup slightly to taste.
Background: Pear tends to get overlooked once apple season arrives, but its delicate sweetness works especially well with botanical spirits such as gin. Ginger gives this one enough spice to keep it firmly in fall territory.
Preparation: Shake gin, pear nectar, lemon juice and simple syrup with ice. Strain into an ice-filled Collins glass. Top with ginger beer and stir gently. Garnish with a pear slice.
TPS Tip: Choose a London Dry gin if you want the juniper and botanicals to stand up against the fruit and ginger. A softer contemporary gin will produce a more fruit-forward cocktail.
Background: Rather than dumping cinnamon directly into a cocktail, this variation incorporates it through a flavored syrup. The result still tastes like a Whiskey Sour—just one that's dressed for October.
For the cinnamon syrup: Combine equal parts sugar and water with 2–3 cinnamon sticks. Heat gently until the sugar dissolves, remove from heat, and allow the cinnamon to steep as the syrup cools.
Preparation: Shake bourbon, lemon, and cinnamon syrup vigorously with ice. If using egg white, dry shake first, then shake again with ice. Strain over fresh ice or serve up.
TPS Tip: Don't substitute cinnamon-flavored whiskey unless that's specifically the flavor you're after. Cinnamon syrup gives you much more control and lets the bourbon remain the star.
Background: Sangria originated in Spain and Portugal, but the American tendency to reinvent it seasonally works in our favor here. Swap summer berries for apples and oranges, add brandy and warming spice, and suddenly sangria makes perfect sense in October.
Preparation: Combine everything except the sparkling water in a pitcher. Refrigerate for at least 2 hours; 4–6 hours is better. Just before serving, add sparkling water and pour over ice.
TPS Tip: Don't use an expensive bottle of wine—but don't use bad wine, either. A fruity, inexpensive Spanish red such as Garnacha or Tempranillo is ideal. If you wouldn't drink the wine by itself, putting fruit in it isn't going to save it.
Whether you’re planning a football watch party or just sitting by the fire pit with friends, The Party Source has everything you need to make fall cocktails that will warm you up and impress your friends.
We also offer in-store pickup, curbside pickup, and local delivery! Delivery in Northern Kentucky requires a $35.00 minimum and a $5.00 delivery fee. We can have curbside/in-store pickup ready in as little as 2 hours. All customers receive a notification via email/text when their order is ready for pickup. We also offer same-day Delivery; orders are ready in as little as 2 hours.
Cheers! And stay warm.